We earn commissions from brands listed on this site, which influences how listings are presented.
Last updatedNovember 2025

Best Pet Insurance Providers in Ohio 2025

Get your vet bills covered

Your furry friend deserves the very best health care! Compare top insurers now.

Background Image
All Pets
All Pets
Cat
Cat
Dog
Dog
1
Fast Repaymenticon
Spot Pet Insurance
Our Top Choice
Read Review
Your Choice of VetYour Choice of Vet
Customizable coverage for puppies and kittens
  • Up to 90% reimbursement
  • VetAccess™ 24/7 vet helpline
  • Save 10% for eligible multiple pets
  • Optional accident-only and wellness plans
9.6
Excellent
View Plans
855-677-8978
2
Lemonade
Customized pet coverage to meet your specific needs
  • Plans starting at $10/mo.
  • Easy access through mobile app
  • Multi-policy discounts available
  • Super fast claims payout: get paid in minutes
9.3
Excellent
VISIT SITE
3
HealthyPaws
No maximum annual or lifetime payout limits
  • Backed by Chubb, a trusted insurance leader
  • Covers illness, accidents & hereditary issues
  • Most claims are processed within 2 days
8.7
Very good
4
ASPCA Pet Health Insurance
Choose complete or accident-only coverage
  • Online member center
  • 10% discount for multiple pets
  • Customize a plan specifically for your pet
8.6
Very good
5
Pets Best
Protect your pet starting at just $1/day
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Fast & easy claims process
  • Provides coverage for 900,000+ pets
9.0
Excellent
6
Pumpkin
Get 80% or 90% back on eligible bills
  • 98% vet approval rating in 2024*
  • PumpkinNow pays eligible vet bills directly
  • Rated 4.5★ from 2,000+ Google reviews¹
8.5
Very good
7
Metlife
Coverage for pets of any age and breed
  • Get a quote in 2 minutes or less
  • Reimbursement for up to 90% of vet costs
  • One of the shortest waiting periods for accident and illness coverage
8
WagWalking.com
Pet Insurance for accidents, illness & routine wellness
  • Easily compare providers side-by-side
  • Affordable pet insurance for any budget
  • Covers accidents, illnesses & wellness
8.7
Very good
9
Includes more coverage at no extra charge
  • Pays back up to 90% of unexpected vet bills
  • Covers accidents, illnesses, diagnostics & treatment at any licensed vet
  • Approved claims paid in as little as 2 days
7.6
Fair
10
Embrace
Flexible plans, up to 90% coverage
  • 24/7 PawSupport health line
  • 75% faster claims process with AI platform Apollo
  • Curable pre-existing conditions covered

12,184 visitors

insured their pet via BestMoney this week

Site Proof Icon
BestMoney Total Score
Our product scores consist of a combination of the following 3 components:
Popularity
BestMoney measures user engagement based on the number of clicks each listed brand received in the past 7 days. The number of clicks to each brand will be measured against other brands listed in the same query. Therefore, the higher the share of clicks a brand receives in any specific query, the higher the Click Trend Score. BestMoney accepts advertising compensation from companies, which impacts their (and/or their products’) position, and in some cases, may also affect their Click Trend Score.
Brand Reputation
Semrush is a trusted and comprehensive tool that offers insights about online visibility and performance. The BestMoney Total Score will consist of the brand's reputation from Semrush. The brand reputation is based on Semrush's analysis of clickstream data, which includes user behavior, search patterns, and engagement, to accurately measure each brand's prominence, credibility, and trustworthiness. If a brand does not have a Semrush score, the BestMoney Total Score will be based solely on the Click Trend Score and Products & Features Score (read below).
Features & Benefits
BestMoney’s editorial team researches and reviews financial products based on factors such as: range of products and services offered, ease-of-use, online accessibility, customer service, special awards, and more. Each brand is then given a score based on the offerings in each parameter. The specific parameters which we use to evaluate the score of each product can be found on its review page.
Editorial Reviews
Spot Pet Insurance
Spot Pet Insurance
Read Review
View all reviews

Must Reads

The Most Common Pet Health Issues and How Much They'll Cost You
Nov 09, 2025
How to Cancel Pet Insurance: A Step-by-Step Guide
Sep 10, 2025
Cheapest Pet Insurance Providers for Dogs & Cats 2025
Sep 29, 2025
Read all articles
Best Overall Insurer
Most Popular On BestMoney
Spot Pet Insurance
Our Top Choice
Your Choice of VetYour Choice of Vet
Customizable coverage for puppies and kittens
  • Up to 90% reimbursement
  • VetAccess™ 24/7 vet helpline
  • Save 10% for eligible multiple pets
  • Optional accident-only and wellness plans
FAQ
1. What is pet insurance and how does it work?
Pet insurance helps cover unexpected veterinary costs in case your pet gets sick or injured. You pay a monthly premium, and when you file a claim for covered expenses, the insurance company reimburses you based on your policy terms.
2. What does pet insurance typically cover?
Pet insurance coverage varies by provider, but most plans typically cover accidents, such as broken bones, swallowed objects, and injuries. They also cover illnesses, including infections, digestive issues, cancer, and diabetes, as well as emergency care and hospitalizations. Medications and surgeries are usually included, and some plans offer optional wellness coverage for routine care, such as vaccinations and checkups.
3. How much does pet insurance cost?
The cost of pet insurance varies based on several factors. Your pet’s species, breed, and age play a role, as older pets and certain breeds may cost more to insure. The level of coverage and deductible you choose also affects the price, with higher coverage leading to higher premiums. Additionally, your location can impact the cost, as veterinary care costs vary by region. On average, pet insurance can cost $15–$50 per month for dogs and $10–$30 per month for cats.
4. When is the best time to get pet insurance?
It’s best to enroll your pet while they’re young and healthy, before any pre-existing conditions develop. Most providers allow coverage for puppies and kittens as early as 6-8 weeks old. However, many insurers offer coverage with no upper age limit, so you can still start coverage even if your pet is older. Just keep in mind that premiums may be higher, and some conditions may be excluded if they were diagnosed before you enrolled.

What Is Pet Insurance?

Pet insurance is a policy that helps cover the cost of veterinary treatments for your pet. Whether it’s a dog, cat, or exotic pet, you pay a monthly premium to receive reimbursement for eligible medical expenses like surgeries, medication, and diagnostics. You can customize your plan based on deductible, reimbursement level, and annual limit.

Why Pet Insurance Is More Popular Than Ever

Veterinary costs are surging due to advancements in pet healthcare. A single surgery can cost over $5,000, and treatment for chronic illnesses like cancer often exceeds $10,000. With more pet owners treating pets as family, demand for comprehensive and affordable pet insurance is rising—especially in states like California, Texas, and Florida.

When Should You Get Pet Insurance?

The best time to purchase pet insurance is when your pet is young and healthy. Many plans exclude pre-existing conditions, making early enrollment a smart move. While older dogs and senior cats can still be insured through many pet insurance providers, senior pet owners should expect higher premiums and possible coverage limits.

How Does Pet Insurance Work?

  1. Explore quotes by entering your pet’s age, breed, and location. 
     
  2. Choose your plan: adjust your deductible, reimbursement %, and coverage cap.

  3. Submit claims after veterinary visits—some providers pay vets directly; others reimburse you.

  4. Receive payment in days to weeks, depending on the provider.

What Does Pet Insurance Cover?

Different plans may vary, but most pet insurance plans include coverage for:

  • Accidents and emergencies

  • Illnesses and hereditary conditions

  • Diagnostic tests (X-rays, MRIs)

  • Surgeries and hospitalization

  • Prescription meds and supplements

  • Behavioral therapy

  • Optional: Wellness and dental care

Most providers do not cover pre-existing conditions, cosmetic procedures, or breeding costs.

How Much Is Pet Insurance?

The cost of pet insurance can depend on:

  • Breed and age

  • Location

  • Deductible (e.g., $50 to $1,000)

  • Reimbursement rate (e.g., 70%, 80%, 90%)

  • Annual limit (e.g., $5,000 or unlimited)

For example:

  • Pet insurance for a 1-year-old cat may cost $9–$33/month depending on the deductible.

  • Pet insurance for a 5-year-old dog in Texas could cost $25–$80/month based on coverage levels.

Pet Insurance Comparison: What to Look For

To find the best pet insurance companies, compare:


Feature

Low-Tier Plan

High-Tier Plan

Deductible

$500–$1,000

$50–$250

Reimbursement Rate

70%

Up to 90%

Annual Limit

$5,000

Unlimited

Wellness Add-ons

Not included

Optional

Direct Vet Pay

Rare

Available in some


Pet Insurance Near Me

Providers typically adjust pricing by ZIP code, so pet insurance in California could have a completely different Premium compared to pet insurance in Texas, or Florida. You can always use a quote tool to compare pet insurance providers and find the cheapest pet insurance options in your area.

What to Avoid in a Pet Insurance Plan

Based on patterns we’ve seen across industry research and real-world pet owner experiences, there are a few things to watch out for when comparing pet insurance plans. These aren’t hard rules—just common pitfalls that many people overlook until it’s too late.

Here are some things that could end up costing you more in the long run:

  • No coverage for hereditary or breed-specific conditions, especially for purebred pets

  • High deductibles paired with low annual limits, which can reduce your actual payout

  • Exclusions on long-term or chronic condition care, which may leave gaps in ongoing treatment

  • Vague definitions of pre-existing conditions, which could impact claim approval

  • Lack of direct vet payment options, leading to upfront out-of-pocket expenses

  • Lengthy waiting periods, leaving your pet uncovered during early days of enrollment

Taking a little extra time to read the fine print and compare providers can make a big difference down the line, especially if your pet ever needs serious care.

Pet Insurance Explained: Some common questions

What does pet insurance cover?

Most plans cover accidents, illnesses, surgeries, and medications. Some include wellness exams if you choose a higher-tier plan.

Is pet insurance worth it?

If your pet requires unexpected care, insurance can save thousands. It's especially worth it for breeds prone to illness or if you live in a high-cost state.

How much is pet insurance per month?

Average costs range from $10–$50 depending on your pet’s age, breed, and chosen coverage.

Can I get pet insurance for senior cats or older dogs?

Yes, but coverage may be limited and premiums will be higher. Early enrollment is ideal.

What is the cheapest pet insurance?

Cheap plans exist but often have high deductibles or limited coverage. Compare quotes carefully to avoid underinsurance.

How do I choose the best pet insurance?

Compare providers on deductibles, reimbursements, exclusions, and customer reviews. Look for providers that cover breed-specific conditions.

What is the best pet insurance for dogs?

Plans that include orthopedic, cancer, and emergency care are ideal for dogs, especially large breeds or purebreds.

Is puppy insurance different from adult dog insurance?

Yes. Puppy plans may include vaccines and early wellness, while adult dog plans focus more on illness and injury.

Can I bundle pet insurance with other policies?

Some insurers offer multi-pet or household discounts, but bundling with home or auto insurance is rare.

Summary: Is Pet Insurance Worth It?

Yes—pet insurance is worth it for many pet owners, especially if your dog or cat faces unexpected illnesses or injuries. With the rising cost of veterinary care in the USA, pet health insurance offers a financial buffer that can save you thousands in emergency treatments. Choosing the best pet insurance plan ensures peace of mind and timely care without compromising your budget.

Disclaimers:

For terms and conditions, visit: https://www.pumpkin.care/sample-plan/. Products are underwritten by either Independence American Insurance Company (NAIC #26581), or United States Fire Insurance Company (NAIC #21113), and produced by Pumpkin Insurance Services Inc. (“Pumpkin”) (NPN #19084749; CA License #6001617).

Pumpkin Now: Qualified customers with eligible claims for treatments $1k or more could be paid in 15 minutes after submitting a request if their bank accepts real-time payments. For a list of RTP-enabled banks, visit https://www.theclearinghouse.org/payment-systems/rtp/rtp-participating-financial-institutions. For full terms & conditions, visit www.pumpkin.care/pn-terms

* Based on responses from 160 veterinary staff members who participated in the "Pumpkin pet insurance veterinary hospital partner feedback survey" between 2/5/24-5/22/24. 161/165 (98%) of respondents said they'd recommend Pumpkin as a pet insurance to learn about.

1 Based on data collected from Google search https://www.google.com/search?q=pumpkin+pet+insurance conducted 04/07/25.