Prudent Pet Review

ByBestmoney StaffDec. 30, 2020
This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Please be advised that the operator of this site accepts advertising compensation from certain companies that appear on the site, and such compensation impacts the location and order in which the companies (and/or their products) are presented, and in some cases may also impact the scoring that is assigned to them. The scoring that appears on this site is determined by the site operator in its sole discretion, and should NOT be relied upon for accuracy purposes. In fact, Company/product listings on this page DO NOT imply endorsement by the site operator. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. The information which appears on this site is subject to change at any time.

In a Nutshell

Prudent Pet Insurance has been rated 4.75 out of 5 stars by customers on Trustpilot. Their policies are simple to buy and manage online. The company offers excellent customer service along with a 30-day money back guarantee. Plans include Accident-only, Essential, Ultimate, and Wellness Care options for dogs and cats in the United States.


  • 24-hour Live Vet Chat for all customers
  • Never denies coverage due to age or breed
  • Plans start as low as $5/month


  • Preventative care is extra
  • No coverage for exotic pets

Prudent Pet Prudent Pet Visit Site

Prudent Pet at a Glance

Pets covered Dogs, Cats
Waiting period
14 days
$100 / $250 / $500
Reimbursement model
70% / 80% / 90%
Suitable For
Responsive customer service


Prudent Pet Insurance launched in October 2018. For a new player, it makes a good first impression, offering multiple ways of getting personalized advice from its customer service team. It’s also easy to get a free quote on their site to determine the cost of your pet’s policy up front. Prudent Pet offers two plans, Accident & Illness and Accident-Only for dogs and cats. One of the main benefits is their Wellness Care Coverage, which covers many bases not covered by most standard forms of pet insurance.  

What's Covered?

Prudent Pet offers two policies with an optional add-on. The first policy is for Accident-only coverage. It is their most basic plan and spans a rather comprehensive list of expenses which includes certain costs other providers might cover under illness policies. The second policy is its Accident & Illness plan. It includes cancer treatments, such as chemotherapy and radiation, alternative therapies sometimes not included by their competitors as well as treatment for behavioral problems. The optional add-on is for Preventative Care. It provides benefits for wellness exams, flea and tick medication, dental cleaning and more.  For a complete list of plan benefits visit their site or contact their customer service team.

Eligible Accident expenses:

  • Alternative therapy
  • End of life expenses
  • Intravenous (IV) fluids and medications
  • Medical supplies
  • MRI or CT scans and x-rays
  • Poison control consultation fees
  • Prescription food to treat a covered condition (not for maintenance or prevention)
  • FDA-approved prescription medications 
  • Stem cell therapy
  • Supplements to treat a covered condition (not for maintenance or prevention)
  • Tooth Extractions
  • Veterinary treatment, including examinations, consultations, and laboratory tests

Preventative Care add-on benefits:

  • Dental cleaning
  • Spay/neuter
  • Wellness exam
  • Deworming
  • Health certificate
  • Flea/heartworm prevention
  • DHLPP vaccine/titer or feline FVRCP vaccine/titer
  • Rabies or Lyme vaccine/titer or feline FIP vaccine/titer
  • Bordetella vaccine/titer
  • Fecal test
  • Heartworm test or feline FELV test
  • Blood test
  • Urinalysis

Insurance Plans & Pricing

Like most pet insurance companies, Prudent offers accident-only and accident & illness coverage. Prices vary radically by age, breed, level of deductible, reimbursement, and policy limit—with particularly expensive coverage for older dogs. 

Costs also vary ever-so-slightly from state to state. For example, where an Illinois resident would pay $19.33 for accident-only or $52.20 for accident & illness for a 10-year-old domestic cat, a California resident would pay $17.57 or $47.45. 

For an additional $10/month ($120/year), Prudent throws in seven preventive benefits with up to $250/year in coverage. For $25/month, your pet gets 12 preventive benefits with up to $450/year in coverage.

The standard coverage is a $250 deductible, 80% reimbursement, and $15,000 policy limit. For example, for a 6-year-old dog, if you lower the deductible to $100 but keep the 80% reimbursement and $15,000 policy limit, you would pay $19.89 for accident-only and $60.39 for accident & illness.

Their site is exceptionally user-friendly and it takes only a few seconds to get an online quote to see how much your pet’s policy will cost you. Just provide your pet’s name, breed, age, sex, and your zip code and email address to get an instant quote on the site. You’ll also receive an email containing your pet’s quote to refer to when you’re ready to purchase a plan. 

The following tables show the cost of buying Accident-only and Accident & Illness coverage, using the examples of a Labrador Retriever and common/domestic cat in Illinois. The tables show what happens when deductible, reimbursement, or policy limit are raised or lowered. 

Deductible (Accident-only/Accident & Illness)

Animal, Age $250 $500
Dog, 6 y.o. $17.57 /$47.45 $14.83 /$38.12
Dog, 10 y.o. $28.59 /$153.74 $23.72 /$125.80
Cat, 6 y.o. $19.33 /$33.41 $16.31 /$26.83
Cat, 10 y.o. $19.33 /$52.20 $16.31 /$41.93

Reimbursement (Accident Only/Accident & Illness)

Animal, Age 80% 90%
Dog, 6 y.o. $17.57 /$47.45 $18.80 /$51.72
Dog, 10 y.o. $28.59 /$153.74 $30.77 /$166.26
Cat, 6 y.o. $19.33 /$33.41 $20.68 /$36.42
Cat, 10 y.o. $19.33 /$52.20 $20.68 /$56.90

Policy Limit (Accident Only/Accident & Illness)

Animal, Age $15,000 Unlimited
Dog, 6 y. o $17.57 /$47.45 $20.96 /$56.61
Dog, 10 y.o. $28.59 /$153.74 $34.10 /$183.39
Cat, 6 y.o. $19.33 /$33.41 $23.06 /$39.85
Cat, 10 y.o. $19.33 /$52.20 $23.06 /$62.26

What's Not Covered

The following is not covered by Prudent Pet’s accident & illness coverage:

  • Pre-existing conditions
  • Cosmetic procedures
  • Breeding costs

Waiting Periods

Prudent has a 14-day waiting period for coverage, comparable to their competitors. This means your pet’s coverage will only become active within 14 days of the policy’s start date. There is a 5-day waiting period for accident-only plans. If your pet suffers from illness or injury during the waiting period, it will not be covered, and its illness will be considered pre-existing. However, an injury or illness that is cured and doesn’t show symptoms or require treatment for 180 days will no longer be regarded as pre-existing, and will, therefore, qualify for coverage.

Coverage Limits

Customers may choose from either one of the following annual coverage limits: $10,000 or unlimited. Not all insurers offer unlimited coverage. While this type of coverage is usually extremely expensive, it’s a good choice if you’re worried about ever having to pay for super-expensive surgery or treatment that would otherwise break the bank.

Reimbursement and Deductibles

Deductibles range between $100, $250, and $500 annual deductibles. Reimbursements range between 70%, 80%, and 90%. As an example, if you have a $250 deductible and 80% reimbursement, and you’re billed for $1,000 in a particular year, you’d get back 80% of $750, or $600. You’d pay the remaining $400 out of your own pocket.

Claims and Service

Submitting claims is quick and easy with Prudent Pet’s fast AI claims technology. The innovative Artificial Intelligence allows for the quickest reimbursement for all claims. Prudent Pet lets policyholders download a claims form from their online policy portal which they can attach to vet receipts and send in by email, mail, fax, or directly through the online policy portal. Prudent Pet reimburses customers via check or direct deposit. Customers may also call or email customer support for updates.

We Suggest Adding on Preventative Care

For a small additional fee, you can choose from 3 levels (low, medium, and high) of wellness care for your pet. The basic preventive package is worth noting, offering dental cleaning, wellness exam, deworming, health certificate, flea and heartworm prevention, and additional benefits, for just $10/month. 

What Prudent Pet Could Do Better

Prudent Pet’s costs are competitive for younger dogs, but they progress for older pets. More affordable options for senior pets could provide additional customer loyalty. 

How Prudent Pet Compares

Here’s how Prudent Pet stacks up against their top competitors. Consider the waiting periods, deductibles and maximum coverage amounts when you choose the company for your pet. 

Illness waiting period Deductibles
Prudent Pet 14 days

$100 to $500

Pets Best 14 days $50 to $1,000
ASPCA 30 days $100 to $500
Embrace 14 days $200 to $1,000

Contact Details and Address

Prudent Pet Insurance offers friendly customer service by live online chat, a toll-free phone number, email, and connecting on their Facebook page. 

5101 Darmstadt Rd

Hillside IL


Prudent Pet Prudent Pet Visit Site

Pet insurance products are produced and administered by Prudent Pet Insurance Agency, LLC (NPN  #18778951). Plans are underwritten by Markel Insurance Company and Markel American Insurance Company.

Prudent Pet customer testimonials

ExcellentReviews 268
TrustPilot is the world’s most powerful review platform, free and open to all.
  • author
    Jan 09, 2021
    We were very happy with the help we got…

    We were very happy with the help we got from Monica


  • author
    Charles Davidson
    Dec 30, 2020
    Great Service/Summary & Receipt

    Monica was great in answering all of my questions and provided high-quality service. My only request is that there is some sort of automated means to provide me with a receipt of payment as well coverage summary, post call.


  • author
    Dec 29, 2020

    Customer service was done by Monica and she was very professional and knowledgeable and made selecting the right tier for Monty a breeze.Thank you. Will be referring many more to Prudent Pet Insurance:)


  • author
    Dec 15, 2020
    Health Insurance for our New Puppy

    This is the first time I have ever purchased pet insurance for any of our dogs, but after raising several dogs and experiencing the high costs associated with their medical care due to illnesses, I feel great relief knowing we have Prudent Pet's comprehensive coverage if and when the need arises. The sales agent, Monica, helped me to enroll our pet and she answered all my questions and made the process quick and easy.


  • author
    Dec 13, 2020
    Very Responsive

    Everyone was so responsive, helpful and efficient.


Prudent Pet