HELOC vs. Personal Loan: Which Is Right for Your Home Improvement Project?

HELOC Rates

• 6.15% - 8.65% APR (variable, average ~7.8%)
• Start lower due to collateral
• Can increase to 12-14% if the Federal Reserve raises rates
• Interest-only payments during the draw period create artificially low initial costs

Personal Loan Rates

• 6.5% - 36% APR (fixed, average ~11.1%)
• Higher due to unsecured lending
• Remain fixed regardless of market conditions
• Fully amortized payments ensure a steady balance reduction

Real-world example: A $30,000 renovation financed through a HELOC at 8% variable costs approximately $200 monthly in interest initially (interest-only), but could increase to $300-350 monthly if rates rise to 12-14%. The same amount borrowed through a personal loan at 11% fixed costs $653 monthly (principal plus interest) with complete certainty for the full 60-month term.

"In 2025, HELOC approvals are more strict. Lenders want proof that the renovation will add value and that borrowers have stable income. A clear project plan can help secure better terms," explains Shawn Davis, NMLS #241983, Licensed Mortgage Broker.

When to Choose a HELOC for Home Improvement

A HELOC can be a powerful tool when your equity, income, and renovation plan are all aligned. It allows you to borrow as needed, which can be helpful for projects that unfold over time. Here's when a HELOC would be a stronger choice:

• You have substantial equity: Your home has at least 15-20% equity remaining after the line of credit.
• Your income is steady: You can absorb potential payment increases if rates rise.
• Your project has phases: Renovations spanning 12-24 months with distinct phases, which allows you to avoid interest charges on funds you won't need for months.
• Costs are uncertain: Whole-house remodels exceeding $50,000 benefit from draw-as-needed flexibility for unexpected structural issues.

Real-Life Success Story: Using a HELOC to Renovate

A homeowner used a HELOC to renovate their kitchen in strategic phases. By borrowing gradually and only drawing funds when invoices arrived, they saved over $4,000 in interest. Once the appraisal was completed, the home value had increased by 12%, more than covering the renovation costs.

The key was timing, restraint, and planning, not rushing.

HELOC Variable Rate Warning

A HELOC usually starts with an attractive rate, but that rate doesn't stay still. Check the rate cap and when the rate resets. A low rate today can transition into a financial strain later if income becomes inconsistent.

When to Choose a Personal Loan for Home Improvement

Some projects don't require large sums of money. They require speed, stability, and simplicity. That's when a personal loan may make more sense. A personal loan might be a better choice:

• Limited equity: You don't have at least 20% equity remaining after the new loan.
• Need speed: You need funding within days for contractor deposits or material purchases.
• Prefer certainty: You want fixed monthly payments that won't increase with market rates.
• Smaller project: Your project is under $40,000-$50,000 with a fixed contractor bid.
• Risk-averse: You prioritize protecting your home above minimizing interest costs.

This route protects borrowers who don't want their home tied to the loan or who prefer a shorter repayment timeline.

Cautionary Example of Using a Personal Loan

A borrower financed a full basement remodel with a personal loan at 15.9% interest. The renovation increased the home value, but only by 5%. Over time, they ended up paying far more in interest than the value gained on the property. The project wasn't the problem. The timing and the loan structure were.

HELOC vs. Personal Loan Tax Deductions

The IRS allows deductions only when the borrowed money improves the structure, lifespan, or functionality of the home, not just the look of it.

• HELOC tax deductibility: Allowed only if the borrowed funds finance qualified home improvements that add value or extend the lifespan of your home.

• Personal loan tax deductibility: Not deductible, as these loans are considered personal or consumer debt regardless of use.

• Qualifying improvements: Structural repairs, insulation, roof replacement, HVAC upgrades, and other major improvements typically qualify.

• Non-qualifying projects: Cosmetic upgrades such as new flooring or luxury bathroom remodels don't qualify for tax deductions.

• IRS rules deduction rules: Deductions apply only when funds are used to build, buy, or substantially improve your home, securing the loan.

How to Decide Between HELOC and Personal Loan

Before signing anything, ask:

• Will this renovation truly increase my home value? Not all projects return their cost.
• Is my cash flow strong enough for the repayment schedule? Factor in potential rate increases if choosing a HELOC.
• Do I need all the money up front, or only in phases? This determines whether HELOC flexibility matters.
• Is this renovation necessary, or emotional? Sometimes waiting builds more than borrowing ever could.
• If the market shifts, will this loan still make sense? Consider job stability and economic conditions.

Default Consequences: HELOC Foreclosure vs. Personal Loan Credit Damage

The collateral difference between HELOCs and personal loans creates dramatically different consequences for borrowers who can't maintain payments.

HELOC Foreclosure Risk

Your home secures the HELOC exactly like your primary mortgage. Missing payments triggers the same foreclosure process, potentially resulting in home loss. This risk persists even if you've built substantial equity. Some homeowners underestimate this risk, viewing HELOCs as "different" from mortgages. Legally, they're not.

Personal Loan Credit Damage

Defaulting on a personal loan damages your credit score severely (drops of 100+ points), triggers collection activity, and may result in legal judgment and wage garnishment. However, you can't lose your home specifically due to personal loan default.

Conclusion: HELOC vs. Personal Loan

Choosing between a HELOC and a personal loan depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and needs for flexibility. A HELOC can offer lower interest rates and larger borrowing limits, but it puts your home at risk and comes with variable payments. Personal loans provide fixed payments and quicker access without risking your home, though often at higher rates.

To find the best fit for your situation, compare our top personal loan lenders to get competitive rates, transparent terms, and expert support tailored to your needs.

Methodology

• Data sources: Information was gathered from IRS Publication 936 on home mortgage interest deductions, current HELOC rate analysis from The Mortgage Reports, and HELOC product details from Navy Federal Credit Union. Additional expert perspectives were contributed by Leanora Benjamin, mortgage loan officer.

• Expert review: Loan features, interest rate ranges, qualification criteria, and tax implications were verified by Leanora Benjamin to ensure accuracy and relevance.

• Limitations: Interest rates and loan availability fluctuate based on Federal Reserve policy, lender practices, and borrower profiles. Figures reflect typical ranges as of November 2025 and may vary.

• Transparency note: BestMoney.com is committed to objective, editorially independent content that empowers consumers to make informed financial decisions on home improvement financing.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What credit score do I need for competitive rates on each option?

Personal loans require minimum scores of 670-700 for competitive rates below 12%, with the best rates (under 10%) requiring 740+. HELOCs typically require 680+ for approval and 720+ for best rates. Lower scores drastically increase personal loan rates while potentially disqualifying you from HELOCs.

2. How quickly can I access funds from each option?

Personal loans typically fund within 1-7 business days after approval. HELOCs require 2-4 weeks due to home appraisal requirements, title search, and closing procedures. The timeline difference matters significantly if contractors require immediate deposits.

3. What happens if my home value drops after I take out a HELOC?

Declining home values don't affect existing HELOCs unless you default. However, lenders may reduce your credit limit or freeze your line if your loan-to-value ratio exceeds their risk thresholds. Personal loans remain unaffected by home value changes since they're unsecured.