- Home/
- Car Insurance /
- Farmers vs. State Farm Car Insurance: Which is Better in 2026?
Farmers vs. State Farm Car Insurance: Which is Better in 2026?
July 27, 2026
July 27, 2026
When it comes to choosing between two of the largest and most well-known car insurance companies in the United States, deciding between Farmers and State Farm can feel like flipping a coin. Both companies are nationally recognized insurers with a strong agent network and decades of experience serving drivers across the country.
However, beneath the surface, Farmers and State Farm aren’t the same. Each car insurance company has its own niche. State Farm is the largest auto insurer in the country, leveraging its massive market share to offer highly competitive rates and consistently above-average customer service.
Farmers, on the other hand, operates slightly differently. While their base rates are significantly higher, they offer a vast, highly customizable menu of coverage add-ons that State Farm lacks. Plus, they serve high-risk drivers.
So, which company deserves to protect your vehicle? We compared Farmers and State Farm head-to-head on rates, coverage options, discounts, and customer satisfaction to help you make the right choice.
For the vast majority of consumers, State Farm is the clear winner. According to recent 2026 data, State Farm’s average rates are significantly cheaper than Farmers across almost every driver profile, from teens to drivers with speeding tickets. State Farm also boasts better customer satisfaction scores from J.D. Power and fewer customer complaints filed with the NAIC.
Farmers, however, is the better option if you require specialized, robust policy add-ons. It’s particularly appealing if you have a traffic violation on your driving record, such as a speeding ticket or DUI. Also, if you drive a brand-new vehicle and want Gap Insurance or New Car Replacement coverage, or if you insist on using Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts for repairs, Farmers provides these options, whereas State Farm does not.
Here’s a quick breakdown of how Farmers and State Farm compare:
Farmers | State Farm | |
Best for | High-risk drivers and those seeking more add-ons | Drivers who prioritize affordable rates and personalized service |
Average car insurance costs | Significantly higher rates | Lower average rates |
Local agent network | Over 48,000 exclusive and independent agents nationwide | About 19,000 agents nationwide |
AM Best financial strength rating | A (Excellent) | A+ (Superior) — downgraded from A++ in Nov. 2025 |
NAIC complaint levels | More complaints than expected for its size | Fewer complaints than expected for its size |
Customer satisfaction | Below-average J.D. Power scores | Above-average J.D. Power scores |
Gap insurance, new car replacement, accident forgiveness, and OEM parts coverage | Yes | No |
Telematics program discount | Up to 15% | Up to 30% |
Why We Like It: State Farm manages to pair the personalized touch of a dedicated local agent with the low rates typically reserved for digital-only, budget insurers. Their Drive Safe & Save telematics program is one of the best in the industry, and its financial strength remains among the strongest in the industry even after a recent ratings adjustment.
Pros:
Significantly cheaper average rates for full and minimum coverage.
Excellent rates for teen drivers and families.
Consistently high customer satisfaction and claims handling ratings.
Massive network of nearly 19,000 local agents nationwide.
Cons:
Lacks popular coverage add-ons like Gap Insurance and New Car Replacement.
Strict underwriting means rates can spike significantly after a DUI.
Read our full State Farm review
Why We Like It: Farmers is built for the driver who wants a highly customized, air-tight policy and doesn’t mind paying a premium for it. They offer nearly four times as many coverage add-ons as State Farm, allowing you to tailor a policy exactly to your liking.
Pros:
Industry-leading coverage options, including customized equipment, accident forgiveness, and OEM parts coverage.
More competitive rates for drivers with very poor credit compared to State Farm.
Offers a massive list of highly specific discounts.
Cons:
Average premiums are often double the cost of State Farm’s.
Below-average customer satisfaction scores from J.D. Power.
Higher volume of customer complaints compared to competitors of similar size.
When it comes to affordability, this is largely a one-sided battle. State Farm is cheaper than Farmers in nearly every scenario, often by a staggering margin. On average, a full coverage policy from State Farm costs roughly $1,487 per year ($124/month), while the exact same policy from Farmers averages $3,091 per year ($257/month).
Here is how the two companies compare across different driver profiles:
For Teen Drivers: State Farm is renowned for being friendly to younger, high-risk drivers. Teens pay an average of $1,811 annually for minimum coverage with State Farm. At Farmers, that same teen driver would pay an astronomical average of over $4,200 annually.
For Drivers with a Speeding Ticket: A single ticket will raise your rates with any carrier, but State Farm is much more forgiving. Drivers with a ticket pay around $1,616 a year with State Farm, compared to $4,252 a year with Farmers.
For Drivers with Bad Credit: This is the only area where Farmers occasionally pulls ahead. Because State Farm relies heavily on credit-based insurance scores in states where it is legal, drivers with very poor credit may find slightly better (or less punishing) rates with Farmers.
If State Farm dominates pricing, Farmers completely dominates coverage versatility.
Both companies offer the standard coverages you legally need:
Bodily Injury Liability
Property Damage Liability
Collision
Comprehensive
Uninsured Motorist
Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
Roadside Assistance
Rideshare Insurance
However, Farmers is the clear winner for policy customization. They offer a suite of specialized add-ons that State Farm simply refuses to write:
New Car Replacement: If your new car is totaled within the first two model years or 24,000 miles, Farmers will pay to replace it with a brand-new one of the same make and model.
Gap Insurance: Covers the “gap” between what you owe on your auto loan and the actual cash value of the car if it’s totaled.
Accident Forgiveness: Forgives one at-fault accident for every three years you drive without an incident, preventing your rates from spiking.
OEM Parts Coverage: Ensures your vehicle is repaired with Original Equipment Manufacturer parts rather than cheaper aftermarket alternatives.
(Note: State Farm does not offer Gap Insurance, New Car Replacement, or Accident Forgiveness.)
Both companies offer long lists of standard discounts (multi-vehicle, bundling home and auto, good student, anti-theft devices). While Farmers numerically offers a few more niche discounts (such as occupational discounts for specific professions), State Farm’s discounts usually yield deeper practical savings because they are applied to a much lower base rate.
Telematics (Usage-Based Insurance): Both carriers offer smartphone apps that track your driving habits in real-time, rewarding safe drivers with discounts.
State Farm Drive Safe & Save: This is one of the most generous telematics programs on the market. Simply signing up nets you an immediate discount, and safe driving habits (avoiding hard braking, late-night driving, and speeding) can save you up to 30% at renewal. State Farm also offers the Steer Clear program specifically designed to help drivers under 25 secure massive discounts.
Farmers Signal: Similar to State Farm’s program, Signal tracks driving habits and offers an initial 5% discount for signing up, with the potential for up to 15% off at renewal for safe driving. However, if the app detects distracted driving or harsh braking, it can technically result in a rate increase in certain states.
When you get into an accident, you want an insurer who responds quickly and pays out fairly.
Customer Satisfaction: State Farm routinely outpaces Farmers in third-party customer satisfaction surveys. In J.D. Power’s recent U.S. Auto Insurance Study, State Farm scored above the industry average in most regions, while Farmers consistently ranked below average. Furthermore, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) notes that State Farm receives fewer customer complaints than expected for a company of its massive size, while Farmers receives noticeably more.
Mobile Apps: Both companies invest heavily in their digital experiences. State Farm’s app allows you to easily file and track a claim, upload photos of damage, request roadside assistance, and manage your Drive Safe & Save score. The Farmers app offers similar functionality, but user reviews on the Apple App Store and Google Play indicate State Farm’s app is slightly less buggy and more intuitive to navigate.
Choose Farmers If...
You want the peace of mind that comes with robust, specialized coverages like New Car Replacement, Gap Insurance, or OEM parts coverage.
You are willing to pay a premium in exchange for a highly customized, air-tight insurance policy.
You want a policy that includes Accident Forgiveness to protect your rates from spiking after your first at-fault crash.
You have a very poor credit score and are struggling to find reasonable rates with strict underwriters like State Farm.
Farmers tends to fit drivers who need a little more wiggle room. If you have a speeding ticket on your record, want to insure a teen who just earned their driver’s license, or own a newer car you’d really like to protect, it’s worth considering. From what I see, Farmers can work well for people who are willing to pay a bit more to feel comfortable with their coverage.
Choose State Farm If...
Your primary goal is to secure the most affordable premium without sacrificing the quality of your coverage.
You value a positive customer service experience and want assurance that the claims process will be smooth, backed by high J.D. Power ratings.
You are insuring a teen driver or college student and want to minimize the massive financial impact on your family’s budget.
You prefer having a dedicated local agent who knows you and can provide personalized advice for all your insurance needs.
State Farm often works best for the ‘pretty clean’ drivers. If you have a good driving record without many (or any) violations, solid credit, and can bundle your home and auto coverage, it’s likely your best bet as the discounts can really add up. Also, if you prefer a local agent, it can fit the bill.
No. They are two entirely separate, competing insurance companies. While both originated in the mid-west and cater heavily to agricultural and rural communities (hence the similar names), State Farm is a mutual company based in Illinois, while Farmers is headquartered in California and is a subsidiary of the Zurich Insurance Group.
Based on comprehensive data from J.D. Power, AM Best, and the NAIC, State Farm provides superior customer service and a smoother claims-handling process compared to Farmers.
State Farm is the largest auto insurer in the United States, controlling nearly 19% of the market. This massive scale allows them to distribute risk more efficiently and keep administrative costs low, passing the savings directly to consumers. Farmers has a smaller market share and distributes policies for riskier drivers, which naturally drives up their average base premiums.
State Farm is substantially better for teens and drivers under 25. Not only are State Farm’s base rates for young drivers roughly half the price of Farmers’, but State Farm also offers the Steer Clear educational program, which provides massive premium reductions for young drivers who complete a driving course and maintain a clean record for three years.
Anna Baluch is an insurance and finance expert at BestMoney.com. With over a decade of writing experience, she specializes in insurance, banking, mortgages, personal loans, and retirement planning. Her work has been featured in publications like Forbes, Newsweek, Fox Business, Credit Karma, Insurify, and Realtor.com. Anna holds a bachelor’s in marketing from Northwood University and an MBA from Roosevelt University. Her goal is to empower consumers to make smart financial decisions.
